A sheriff investigating the disappearance of a young girl from a small island discovers there's a larger mystery to solve among the island's secretive, neo-pagan community.
Edward Malus
Nicolas Cage
Sister Summersisle
Ellen Burstyn
Sister Willow
Kate Beahan
Dr. Moss
Frances Conroy
Sister Rose / Sister Thorn
Molly Parker
Sister Honey
Leelee Sobieski
Sister Beech
Diane Delano
Officer Pete
Michael Wiseman
Rowan Woodward
Erika-Shaye Gair
Truck Stop Waitress
Christa Campbell
Station Wagon Mom
Emily Holmes
Station Wagon Girl
Zemphira Gosling
Sea Plane Pilot
Matthew Walker
Sister Oak
Mary Black
Sister Violet
Christine Willes
Daisy
Sophie Hough
Ivy
David Purvis
Village Sister #1
Xantha Radley
Attendant #1
Tania Saulnier
Attendant #2
Anna Van Hooft
School Girl #1
Moraea Bieber
School Girl #2
Jayda Bieber
School Girl #3
Talia Ranger
Female Cop
Kendall Cross
Village Male #1
Simon Longmore
Village Male #2
Andre Danyliu
Blind Twin #1
Jacqueline Robbins
Blind Twin #2
Joyce Robbins
Truck Stop Patron
Aaron Eckhart
Bar Guy #1
James Franco
Bar Guy #2
Jason Ritter
Rams Horn Woman (uncredited)
Monique Ganderton
Villager (uncredited)
George A. Murphy
Villager (uncredited)
Linley Subryan