Beautiful Katie Lapp has always felt something missing in her simple Amish existence -- until a mysterious "Englisher" comes to Lancaster County looking for the baby girl she gave up for adoption 19 years ago.
Katie Lapp
Danielle Panabaker
Laura Mayfield-Bennett
Sherry Stringfield
Jessica
Sarah Maine
Theodore
Willie Stratford
Benjamin Lapp
Jason Loughlin
Rebecca Lapp
Sandra Elise Williams
Samuel Lapp
Bill Oberst Jr.
Jacob Beiler
Wyatt Lanier
Bishop John Beiler
Burgess Jenkins
Hickory John Beiler
Dalton Parrish
Daniel Fisher
David Topp
Ephram Yoder
Richard Fullerton
Ella Mae Zook
Nancy Saunders
Benjamin's Daughter
Rachel St. Gelais
Amanda
Jana Allen
Mary Stoltzfus
Sarah E. Chambers
Preacher Yoder
Jimmy Hager
Amish Elder
David Forrester
Surgeon
Robert C. Treveiler
Trauma Nurse
Stephen West-Rogers
Nurse Rosie
Lee Freeman
Young Laura
Alexa Yeames
Dylan Bennett
Tim Holt
Store Clerk
Michele Lee
Nurse (uncredited)
Lindsey Moser
Amish Man
Scott Helm
Young Amish Bachelor (Uncredited)
Jacob Allen
Young Samuel (Uncredited)
Kirk Bass
Bus Patron (Uncredited)
Leanne Bernard
Bus Patron (Uncredited)
Randy Bernard
Self / Self - Nurse (Uncredited)
Hailey Best
Amish Guy (Uncredited)
Elijah Chester
Amish Man (Uncredited)
Darren W. Conrad
Amish Woman in Shop (Uncredited)
Lee Ryan Coston
Bus Patron (Uncredited)
Christina Cupo
Amish woman (Uncredited)
Beth Gosnell
Wedding Guest (Uncredited)
Beth Hawkes
Amish Woman in Cab (Uncredited)
Tessa Taylor Herrick
Amish Man at General Store (Uncredited)
Nick Karner
Amish Man (Uncredited)
Dan A.R. Kelly
Amish Elder (Uncredited)
Jerry Keys
Amish Woman (Uncredited)
Janine Lorraine
Noah Beiler (Uncredited)
Jason Mac
Young Boy (Uncredited)
Chris Manitius
Hotel Guest (Uncredited)
Shasta Mejia
Young Amish Woman (Uncredited)
Melissa Milch
Amish Girl (Uncredited)
Addy Miller
Young Amish Man (Uncredited)
David R. Moore
Amish Man (Uncredited)
Gary Ray Moore
Young Rebecca (Uncredited)
Tina Murphy
Amish Elder (Uncredited)
David Dickson Reynolds
Amish Woman (Uncredited)
Karen Wheeling Reynolds
Amish Man (Uncredited)
Chris Sprister
Amish Teenager (Uncredited)
Tara-Nicole Warner
Amish Woman (Uncredited)
Brandi Alyssa Young