Advice columnist Dan Burns is an expert on relationships, but somehow struggles to succeed as a brother, a son and a single parent to three precocious daughters. Things get even more complicated when Dan finds out that the woman he falls in love with is actually his brother's new girlfriend.
Dan
Steve Carell
Marie
Juliette Binoche
Mitch
Dane Cook
Jane
Alison Pill
Cara
Britt Robertson
Lilly
Marlene Lawston
Nana
Dianne Wiest
Poppy
John Mahoney
Ruthie Draper
Emily Blunt
Eileen
Amy Ryan
Clay
Norbert Leo Butz
Amy
Jessica Hecht
Howard
Frank Wood
Will
Henry Priest Miller
Rachel
Ella Miller
Elliot
CJ Adams
Jessica
Jessica Lussier
Gus
Seth D'Antuono
Olivia
Margot Janson
Bella
Willa Cuthrell-Tuttleman
Marty Barasco
Felipe Dieppa
Policeman
Matthew Morrison
James Lamson
Bernie McInerney
Cindy Lamson
Amy Landecker
Bookstore Clerk
Steve Mellor
Bowling Alley Manager
Pauline Gregory
Suzanne Burns
Shana Carr
Jane (age 13)
Nicole Morin
Cara (age 11)
Charlotte Davies
Lilly (age 4)
Zoe Pauliks
Lilly's Dance Partner
Lucas Hedges
Himself
Sondre Lerche
The Faces Down Wedding Band (Guitar)
Kato Ådland
The Faces Down Wedding Band (Drums)
Ole Ludvig Krüger
The Faces Down Wedding Band (Bass)
Morten Skage
Wedding Singer
Marci Occhino
NYC Cabbie (uncredited)
John Franchi