A childless couple bury a box in their backyard, containing all of their wishes for an infant. Soon, a child is born, though Timothy Green is not all that he appears.
Cindy Green
Jennifer Garner
Jim Green
Joel Edgerton
Timothy Green
CJ Adams
Joni Jerome
Odeya Rush
Evette Onat
Shohreh Aghdashloo
Brenda Best
Rosemarie DeWitt
James Green, Sr.
David Morse
Franklin Crudstaff
Ron Livingston
Ms. Bernice Crudstaff
Dianne Wiest
Uncle Bub
M. Emmet Walsh
Aunt Mel
Lois Smith
Reggie
Lin-Manuel Miranda
Bobby Crudstaff
William J. Harrison
Joseph Crudstaff
James Rebhorn
Coach Cal
Common
Dash Best
Patrick Brouder
Billy CrudStaff
Chan Creswell
Little Boy in Elevator
Shimei Bailey
Doug Wert
Michael Arden
Doctor Lesley Hunt
Rhoda Griffis
Mother at Doctor's Office
Karan Kendrick
Rod Best
Kendall Ryan Sanders
Ms. Crudstaff's Assistant
Judy Langford
Cop
Michael Beasley
Cop
Cullen Moss
Neighbor
Gene Jones
Bart Best
Jason Davis
Bethany Best
Lucy Gebhardt
Principal Morrison
Sharon Conley
Trixie Crudstaff
Dorothy Vollmer
Ref
Dwayne Boyd
#8
Mattie Liptak
Coach Bob Francesconi
Jay Freer
Mayor Handelman
Tim Ware
Molly Frohn
Susan Bruce
Nurse
Tara Lee
Factory Worker
Joe Crosson
Marty Rader (voice)
Tim Guinee
Alan Rust (voice)
Shaun O'Banion