Nick's plan to let fate bring his wife to him must be altered because he must replace his father as Santa Claus on December 26. Ernst, the right-hand man to several generations of Santas, generates a list of potential mates. Nick dutifully sets off to meet them, but fate may have a candidate after all.
Nicholas Claus
Steve Guttenberg
Elizabeth "Beth" Sawtelle
Crystal Bernard
Jake Swatelle
Dominic Scott Kay
Andrew
Thomas Calabro
Ernest
Armin Shimerman
Hennesy
Sebastian Tillinger
Amy
Wendy Braun
Joanie
Kelley Hazen
Jocelyn
Mackenzie Fitzgerald
Christian
Cody Arens
Meredith
Robin Shorr
Santa
John Wheeler
Coach
Taffy Wallace
Marilyn
Samantha Bennett
Young Beth
Ashlynn Bernard
Holly
Katia Coe
Sir John
Clement von Franckenstein
Mrs. Clauss
Marcia Ann Burrs
Emily
Miranda Gibson
Hearing Impaired Girl
Hannah Wilber
Mall Santa
Austin Miles
Store Clerk
Darby Stanchfield
Woman Customer
Diane Robin
Connor
Erik Carr
Mom of Hearing Impaired Girl
Alison McMillan
Tree Seller
Frank Sharp
Commercial 1st AD
Brandon Keener
Joanna
Mariette Hartley
(Uncredited / voice)
Staci Armao
Basketball Fan (uncredited)
Blaise Brooks
Production Assistant (uncredited)
S. Zev Esquenazi
Elf (uncredited)
Dassler Jimenez
Various Voices (uncredited)
David Rasner