When her idolized twin sister Audrey dies in a car accident, Laurel decides to take her place. But, as she eases into the life she has always wanted, she must decide between continuing the lie or revealing herself.
Laurel / Audrey
Zoe Kazan
Basel
Jake Johnson
Charles
Ron Livingston
Dr. Rao
Danny Pudi
Hunter
Sterling Beaumon
Frank
John Carroll Lynch
Claudia
Frankie Shaw
Edith
Sabrina Lloyd
James
Jeremy Howard
May
Shae D'Lyn
Perfect Mom
Bronwyn Cornelius
Perfect Dad
Patrick Breen
Perfect Boy
Stuart Littlefield
Perfect Girl
Rosa Yelena Schorr
Patrick
Luka Jones
Mrs. Shoemacher
Dale Raoul
Ralph
Mark Kelly
Marguerite
Jennifer Lafleur
Funeral Boy #1
Devan Leos
Funeral Boy #2
William Kronfeld
Peter
Luke Colombero
Halloween Kid
Tyler Nunes
Halloween Kid
Joey Fernandes
Halloween Kid
Vincent Castro
Halloween Kid
Luke Trujillo
Halloween Kid
Isiah Greene
Halloween Kid
Zeve Zilberberg
David Matthews
Michael Alferoff