A matchmaker connects Molly and Jacob, but their new romance is put to the test when they realize that they are competing deli owners. Will a Hanukkah miracle keep them together?
Jacob
Jeremy Jordan
Molly
Yael Grobglas
Ruth
Linda Darlow
Gabe
David Eisner
Eve
Lisa Horner
Stan
Harry Nelken
Esther
Paula Shaw
Thomas
Tim Nhlazane
Ed
Sam Rosenthal
Natalie
Lisa Loeb
Liz
Linda E. Smith
Mrs. Mizansky
Angela Narth
Emo Girl
Cora Matheson
Ezra
Darren Martens
Frank
Dan De Jaeger
Grandmother
Debbie Maslowsky
Owner
Henriette Ivanans
Messenger
Jean-Jacques Javier
Kid
Saul Elias
Mrs. Rosenbaum
Mariam Bernstein
Waitress
Christine Vetus
Crowd Member (uncredited)
Frederick Allen
Gilbert's Deli Regular (uncredited)
Cindy Rose Myskiw
Deli Patron (uncredited)
Lorrie Papadopoulos
Waitress
Angelica Venancio
Pebbles
Tia O'Neill
Donut Boy
Nico Gentes